Welcome to Pepperoni’s Pizza
At Pepperoni’s Pizza, located in Simsbury, Connecticut, we embrace the charm of a classic New England pizza parlor. Our story is built on a commitment to crafting exceptional, handmade pizzas using fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, with our thin crust drawing praise from locals. With a menu boasting popular items like mozzarella and jalapeño poppers, and an inviting atmosphere perfect for families and groups, we aim to provide yummy experiences without breaking the bank. While the ambiance may be simple, it's the genuine warmth of our service and the delightful flavors that keep customers returning for more. Join us for a slice!
Pepperoni’s Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
For thin crust, without traveling to New Haven, this is the best mozzarella pizza around. The pie is cooked in a standard oven so its not wood or coal fired which is next level. This is thin crust, New Haven style. Good value. Not overpriced like the place 100 yards away! Great service. Eating in is nothing fancy but there are a few tables. For this style of pizza, and local to me, this is my first choice.
Tried this place after searching for a thin crust, basic pizza. We were pleasantly surprised! I was a little skeptical when seeing a simple website that looked like it hasn't been updated in a while, and no online ordering or delivery service option (DoorDash, Grubhub, etc), but decided to kick it old school and call in an order. The prep time seemed a bit long for a random weeknight order, but was hot and ready when I arrived to pick up. The restaurant is small, no frills, just a counter with slices for sale and a few booths for seating. I ordered a large pizza with sausage & peppers on half and it was less than $20!! The pizza was great, excellent cheese pull and a nice crispy crust. Not greasy or oily and the sauce had good flavor. My belly and my wallet were satisfied! We will definitely return in the future!
Pepperoni's is your basic pizza restaurant. The handmade dough is excellent (fermented over a couple of days) . It is solid reliable pizza and New York style. The grinders are decent and again exactly what you expect out of a Blodgett Pizza oven. Is this the best pizza around, well maybe not quite but is darned good and if you like classic pizza it is really good. I am not sure I would order much else from here other than pizzas , grinders and calzones. It is a small place and there isn't much of a kitchen. Salads are made with the veggies they use to build grinders. Nothing special but OK for a veggie fix. Ambiance not much. It is classic old school New England pizza parlor which has it is own charm. TV's frequently playing soccer and football (that is not the NFL).
Quite good - have ordered a few times and impressions have been that all ingredients are fresh, cheese and dough not overly salty and the prices are reasonable. Recommended.
There are a lot of pizza places around Granby/Simsbury, and this is the very best if you like excellent New York style. We've been going there for a couple years, the pizzas are consistently great. Fresh ingredients. And the owner and others who work there are friendly and enthusiastic about serving up great pizza.
A friend ordered pizza from the next door pizza shop and I knew there was a better choice. Today I went to pepperonis and saw the sign for New York style pizza; and it was just that. Hot. Cheesy. Nice crunchy crust and Mama Mia the long thin point with the got drippy cheese. True comfort food. Love the pizzeria decor. The unicorn mural. The tables. Made this Nyack NY girl feel at home.
This little pizza place has the corner on the best crust for pizza in the Farmington Valley. Toppings cheese and of course a pepperoni version of their pizza is the go to order and it is uniformly excellent. As Dave Portnoy would say, it's easily an 8.5.
Location
-
1400 Hopmeadow St Simsbury, CT 06070 United States Hotline: (860) 658-5669
Welcome to Pepperoni’s Pizza, a cherished gem located in the heart of Simsbury, Connecticut. Known for its delectable offerings, this unclaimed pizza parlor serves up classic New York-style pies that keep locals coming back for more. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Pepperoni’s is the perfect spot to gather with friends and family over a slice or two.
- Location: 1400 Hopmeadow St, Simsbury, CT 06070, United States
- Phone: (860) 658-5669
Pepperoni’s specializes in thin-crust pizza that strikes the perfect balance of crispiness and flavor. The mozzarella, priced at just $8.99, has garnered rave reviews for its fresh ingredients and satisfying cheese pull. Customers like Greg G. praise its New Haven-style crust, noting that it's the best option for thin crust without having to travel far. Valued for its reasonable prices, Pepperoni’s garners respect as a fantastic choice amidst many competitors in the area.
The menu offers not just pizza but also crowd-pleasing appetizers like jalapeno poppers ($6.25) and delicious chicken wings tossed in savory sauces ($4.19). Don't forget to pair your meal with one of their grinders or calzones, which Jim N. notes are made with handmade dough that's fermented to perfection. The handcrafted quality elevates these traditional favorites, making for a satisfying dining experience.
As you step inside, you’ll notice a simple yet inviting space. Though it’s not extravagant, the ambiance radiates the charm of an old-school New England pizza joint. With moderate noise levels, it's ideal for cozy family meals and casual gatherings with friends. The staff is friendly and enthusiastic, eager to share their passion for pizza with every customer, as Valerie E. highlights in her glowing review. They take reservations, making it easy to secure a spot for those busy weekends.
For families and groups, Pepperoni’s Pizza delivers an impressive selection of vegetarian options, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Whether you choose to dine in or take out, you’ll find that each order comes prepared with care and attention to detail. In a world where dining options abound, Pepperoni’s stands out as a go-to destination for pizza lovers in Simsbury.
In conclusion, if you're in the area and craving satisfying, high-quality pizza without breaking the bank, look no further than Pepperoni’s Pizza. With its delectable offerings, welcoming vibe, and commitment to freshness, it promises a delightful culinary experience that is sure to leave you coming back for more.
